Island hopping for shopping while uninsured is not an emergency – Judge

June 11, 2025

A man living on an island off Donegal told a judge that he drove a car uninsured as he needed to get his groceries.

“It was an emergency,” Oleksandr Karpenko told Judge Eiteáin Cunningham at Letterkenny District Court.

The 32-year-old was stopped on the R251 at Kilmore, at 6.30pm on December 20, 2024 after his Seat Alhambra flashed on the Garda mobility app as an uninsured vehicle.

A lawful demand was made of Karpenko to produce insurance, but he admitted that he had none.

Karpenko represented himself in court and told Judge Cunningham: “It was just an emergency because I don’t usually drive the car”.

Asked about the emergency, Karpenko, who represented himself, added: “I live on an island and I had to buy groceries.

Karpenko resides at Fallagowan, Arranmore Island.

Judge Cunningham told the accused: “You have to buy groceries every week so that is not an emergency. You shouldn’t be driving without insurance.”

Karpenko was convicted and fined €200, but was spared from a disqualification on this occasion.

However, Judge Cunningham warned Karpenko that if he appears in court again for a similar offence that he would be banned from driving for four years.


Tags:

LEAVE A COMMENT